- (no subject)
-

lexaprose
- May 31st, 12:41
It's never good when you can watch a movie on mute, but not without the dialogue running through your head. (excuse me while I pretend I'm not talking about Two Towers)
Though, as much as I love these films, I don't think I'll ever be able to accept their take on Faramir. He's... weak! And corrupted! Yes, he's an awesome plot device (hmmm, how shall we incorporate the events in Gondor so it doesn't seem a total contrivance when Pippin and Gandalf get there?), but... he's not... Faramir!
It's like they wanted Gondor to seem like a total hellhole so that when Aragorn becomes King and everything's shiny again it's *even* *more* *wonderful*. So they emphasize characters like Satan--excuse me, Denethor--and totally fuck over Faramir (and give him really hilarious facial hair) and... well, Boromir's all right, with the extended versions, but in the theatrical versions it's really baffling why Pippin cares so much about these guys. And Imrahil and Beregond are... well...
I still can't watch the end of Fellowship. It's to the point that even my echolalia-enhanced brain can't remember the words. Anyway. I love Gondor. It's really quite unhealthy, isn't it? :D
Also am I the only one who thinks it's odd that Boromir and Faramir are blondish-redheaded (anyone else think there were a bunch of different wigs? Cos Faramir's almost blond in Ithilien, and by the coronation he's basically strawberry) while all the Rangers and, y'know, the *other* Gondorians are dark-haired? If you want to give people non-traditional looks, um, I suppose Elboron could be blond and Elfwine could be dark-haired, both their mothers having emigrated, but they don't actually come into play in the films. Not that it matters. I'm just sayin', it's not easy to love Gondor here. Especially when you can't stop giggling at the Prince of Ithilien's facial hair.
Generally I make an effort to be book-centric in defense of my insane theories, but this one's great: when Faramir is talking to/threatening Sam and Frodo, and Damrod (I think? One of his Rangers) comes in, David Wenham can't keep his eyes still. And if that's intentional, the man has insane small muscle control, because it's like a twitch in fast-forward.
(2000 word essay? What 2000 word essay?)